| Story of the Year The American Way, John Ridley, Georges Jeanty & Karl Story Bluesman Book 3, Rob Vollmar & Pablo Callejo Day 8, Damian Duffy, Deborah Grison & John Jennings Earthlight Vol. 1, Stuart Moore & Christopher Schons Stagger Lee, Derek McCulloch & Shepherd Hendrix |
Rising Star Award Darryl Hughes & Monique MacNaughton, GAAK Mark Page, Kana's Island Felipe Smith, MBQ Spike, Templar, Arizona Masheka Wood, What Masheka Did |
| Best Writer Damian Duffy & Deborah Grison, Day 8 Derek McCulloch, Stagger Lee Stuart Moore, Earthlight Vol. 1 John Ridley, The American Way Rob Vollmar, Bluesman Book 3 |
Best Reprint Publication Deogratias: A Tale of Rwanda, First Second Krazy & Ignatz 1937-38, Fantagraphics Nat Turner Encore Edition Vol. 1, Kyle Baker Publishing Never Made to Last: Stories of Suburban Folklore, Ourobor Books Tokyo Tribes Vol. 5, TokyoPop |
| Best Artist Kyle Baker, The Bakers Shepherd Hendrix, Stagger Lee Jamal Igle, Firestorm Georges Jeanty, The American Way Christopher Schons, Earthlight Vol. 1 |
Best Cover 52 Week 14, J.G. Jones The American Way #2, Georges Jeanty, Karl Story & Randy Mayor Firestorm #23, Brian Stelfreeze Stagger Lee, Shepherd Hendrix Storm #1, Mike Mayhew |
| Best Male Character Infidel, Astro City: Samaritan Lem Taylor, Bluesman Book 3 Mr. Jenkins, Day 8 New American, The American Way Stagger Lee, Stagger Lee |
Best Comic Strip Candorville, Darrin Bell The K Chronicles, Keith Knight Templar, Arizona, Spike (th)Ink, Keith Knight Watch Your Head, Cory Thomas |
| Best Female Character Amo Tanzer, Lucifer's Garden of Verses: Between the Devil and Miles Davis Evelyn Prescott, Stagger Lee Ororo, Storm Sahara, Elephantmen Thomasina Lindo, Welcome to Tranquility |
Fan Award for Best Comic Black Panther: The Bride, Reginald Hudlin, Scot Eaton & Klaus Janson Crisis Aftermath: The Spectre, Will Pfeifer & Cliff Chiang Firestorm #28-32, Stuart Moore, Jamal Igle & Keith Champagne New Avengers #22, Brian Michael Bendis & Leinil Francis Yu Storm, Eric Jerome Dickey, David Yardin & Lan Medina and Jay Leisten & Sean Parsons |